🔥
ReplySmooth
"This is the saddest song ever written" — OkCupid question answers

"This is the saddest song ever written" — OkCupid answers that work

SecretsBy Bhupendra Singh Chauhan · Updated August 13, 2026

On this page
  1. 01How to answer
  2. 02Ready-to-copy answers
  3. 03Answers that work
  4. 04Answers that fall flat
  5. 05The strategy
  6. 06Common questions
  7. 07Related questions

How to answer "This is the saddest song ever written" on OkCupid

This question punishes a joke. It asks what actually moves you, and the defensive one-liner is the most common way people avoid answering it. It also asks which song, so naming no song is not an answer at all. Pick a real title, say it without irony, and let the obvious choice be obvious if that is the true one.

132+ ready-to-copy "This is the saddest song ever written" answers

Tap any line to copy. Pick a strategy chip to filter by angle. Edit before pasting — verbatim copies read flatter.

absurd then true · 16

emotionally revealing · 17

escalating stakes · 16

low stakes confession · 17

playful misdirection · 16

sensory anchor · 16

specific detail · 17

tonal range · 17

Three "This is the saddest song ever written" answers that work

  • emotionally revealing

    Nothing Compares 2 U. Predictable, and I have still never made it to the end of it in a car without needing a minute afterwards.

    Why it works: Names the song, admits the choice is obvious, and gives a physical reaction instead of an explanation. The car detail is what makes it believable.

  • specific detail

    Hallelujah, but only the Jeff Buckley one. The Leonard Cohen version is a different song doing an entirely different job.

    Why it works: A specific, arguable position rather than a title. Defending one version over another is an open invitation to disagree, which is how a reply starts.

  • low stakes confession

    The opening ten minutes of Up, which is technically a score and has beaten me twice this year already.

    Why it works: An unashamed choice, precisely located, with a count attached. Admitting it happened twice this year is the sincerity the question is actually asking for.

Three that fall flat

  • no song named

    Something slow and depressing. I do not really keep track of titles.

    Why it falls flat: Names no song, and the question asked which one. The reader is left with a mood rather than a thing, so there is nothing to agree with or argue about.

  • joke deflection

    Whatever is playing when you decide to leave. 😢

    Why it falls flat: A wink where the question asked for sincerity. It is a fine line on its own, but it says clearly that this person would rather not answer.

  • category not specific

    Anything by Adele, really.

    Why it falls flat: A bucket rather than a song. Naming an artist dodges the specific choice, and the specific choice was the only thing the question wanted.

Name the song. A category — something slow, anything by a particular singer — dodges the only thing being asked, and leaves the reader nothing to agree or argue with. Sincerity is the risk worth taking here: the answers that work either say the obvious one and own it, or defend a specific version over another, which is an invitation to disagree. A film score can be the right answer if it is the true one. What fails is the wink, because the question was already about feeling something and the joke says you would rather not.

Common questions

What is a good answer for "This is the saddest song ever written"?

A real title, said without irony, with a physical reaction rather than an explanation. Needing a minute in the car afterwards tells a reader more than any description of the song could.

Is it bad to pick an obvious song?

No, as long as you own it. Admitting the choice is predictable and standing by it reads as honest, while hunting for an obscure title to seem interesting is usually visible from a distance.

Can I make a joke instead?

You can, and it is the most common answer here, which is the problem. The question asked what moves you, so a wink reads as a refusal and tells the reader you would rather not say.

→ Browse all OkCupid profile questions

All 53 OkCupid profile questions

Every question OkCupid offers, grouped the way the app groups them, each with a sample answer you can copy. Free, no signup.

See all 53 questions

Your AI wingman for Hinge, Bumble & Tinder

Try free